(This isn’t intended to be a review of the movie; it’s just a few observations and questions I had after watching it)
I just watched The Cloverfield Paradox and… I have questions…
First off, I’m going to say that I enjoyed the movie. I found it entertaining: but I’m easily entertained. I don’t go into films expecting to be disappointed like some critics seems to, I go in there looking for a fun story.
Also, it should be noted that although I try to avoid spoilers in general, there will be some spoilers. I’ll be as vague as I can though.
With that said, I will restate my purpose here: I have questions.
- The Arm: How was the arm sentient, and how did it have access to information that the original owner was not privy to?
- The worms: If the worms were teleported INTO the crew member, then why didn’t they just die instantly? Why did it take so long before they exploded out of them?
- The Sick Crew member: Along with #2, why did that crew member have issues with their eye, and NOT with their stomach or abdominal area where they were pumped full of goodies?
- The Husband: What was his purpose? His side story could have been removed without taking anything away from the story.
- The Airlock: Who opened it? Why didn’t they talk about it opening itself?
One of the crew members loses an arm while preparing the station for an upcoming event. Not long afterwards, the arm is discovered crawling around. They discuss the arm briefly and find that the original owner is not in control of the arm, in any way. This raises the question, then, of ‘who controls the arm?’
It is mentioned at a point in the film that they have merged with another dimension and replaced their counterparts… So is it possible that the arm is being controlled by the original crew member of that dimension? Or is the arm just sentient in its own right? Perhaps the universe/paradox itself is using the arm to guide the crew?
That last possibility would explain the next question about the arm: how did it know where the important piece of equipment that would resolve almost everything happened to be? The original owner of the arm didn’t know, and I would assume the alternate dimension version of them also didn’t know… But the arm knew, as if by telepathy. It read the mind of the universe and told everyone else.
Regardless of how the arm knew, another questions arises from the fact that it knew, and could communicate its knowledge. Why didn’t the crew seek any further information from the arm? The arm tells them exactly where they need to look for the missing equipment, then the crew runs off and never comes back to the all knowing, all seeing arm to ask any questions of it. In fact, they don’t even really discuss the arm again. It has a brief appearance later, and that’s it.
After the big event that causes all the chaos, a member of the crew vomits worms. They don’t do this immediately, no: they wait quite a while into the film to do so. So, what were all the worms doing in that time? Presumably, they appeared inside the crew member at the time of the event, when everything went whacky, but they showed no signs of illness until much later… Until someone noticed the worms were gone. If they were full of worms they should have been showing signs of illness or discomfort immediately… Right?
This question connects to the next one pertaining to
The Sick Crew Member
The same individual with the worms seemed to have a lot of other issues. Their eye went crazy on them, dodging about in every direction, and their skin seemed oddly elastic. For a few seconds, they seemed to be hearing voices and even spoke to them. There is no offer of explanation as to who they spoke to or heard. Were they talking to the worms? Their eye maybe? Could this be explained again with two individuals trying to occupy the same space?
And what was with the eye? They’re were pumped full of worms and other things and they only problem he has with that is an itchy eye that turns sideways?
The only thing I can think is maybe the two bodies of the different dimensions merged into one and were having difficulties with body control and voices? The voice could have been the other them? I don’t know…
Besides all that, how were they not aware of the very large foreign object suddenly inside them? An object of that size would have had weight, and been pushing organs all around. It would have very likely been a noticeable bulge in their side. So how did they, or any other member of the crew, not notice?
While everyone is in space doing stuff, the story occasionally flips back to a crew member’s husband back on Earth. His story is short, simple, goes no where, and adds nothing to the rest of the story. He doesn’t fend off monsters, fight a gang, make any amazing revelations, or travel across the country to save anyone. He literally picks a kid up off the street and hides in a bunker.
His entire story arc could have been a sentence at the end of the movie where someone adds in “He’s safe. He found a bunker.” His whole story feels like filler.
Who opened the airlock and why isn’t this a bigger issue? If they all know no one opened it, it just opened on its own, then shouldn’t they be freaking out that their airlocks are opening themselves? They’re in space… That is a VERY BIG problem! I would imagine that would be a bigger discussion.
Speaking of which, I’m adding another point: they never stopped to discuss anything. No one ever had a freak out moment of “WHAT THE HELL IS GOING ON” or eve try to explain anything. They commented once, in passing, ‘the paradox is real’ or something along those lines.
It seems to me that there should have bee a moment where they all sat down, had some coffee, and someone explained what was going on.
Someone should have said “we traveled to another dimension and the universe is creating anomalies, trying to get rid of us to correct for our existence.”
Or something… Anything, really.
Long Story Short
I liked the movie! It was fun, but some parts didn’t make a lot of sense… Like why 3 people HAD to go to the ring when 2 of them did literally nothing while there. Or why they would design the emergency release to only be activated from inside the thing being released? Seems like a big design flaw to me.
No! No more flaws! I liked the movie! I enjoyed it, and it kept a good pace so I was never bored and my mind never wandered off anywhere else.
I understand the whole movie was an explanation for how the original Cloverfield movie came to be, but I feel it could have easily been completely unrelated. I understand it was originally titled “The God Particle” and I think that would have made a lot more sense; Unconnected from the franchise, and a thing all its own.
As I stated at the beginning, this wasn’t intended to be a review… Just a few personal questions and observations, all of which are open for discussion! Please, feel free to open a dialogue by commenting. I would love to hear other opinions, ideas, observations, and questions regarding The Cloverfield Paradox